• feature · movies

Did Miracle on 34th Street Film a Real Macy’s Parade?

The 1947 Christmas movie filmed during the real 1946 Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. See which scenes and balloon came from the actual event.

Aram AnwarBy Aram Anwar · 3 min read
The entrance and corner sign of Macy’s Herald Square flagship store in Manhattan
Macy’s Herald Square in 2022. Scenes for the 1947 movie were shot at this location.Eden, Janine and Jim / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0

The 1947 Miracle on 34th Street used footage from the real Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade in 1946. The production also filmed at the Herald Square store, where its fictional Santa takes the job that sets the rest of the movie in motion.

What did the production film at the real parade?

The AFI Catalog records filming both at Macy’s and during its Thanksgiving parade. TCM’s production history adds that Edmund Gwenn rode on the actual Santa float. So the actor really did wave to a New York crowd as Santa, even though the film’s story about how he got there belongs to the script.

One detail makes the footage easy to place. In the film, Susan recognizes the balloon called Harold the Baseball Player and remembers that he used to be a clown. Macy’s and Twentieth Century Fox identified the balloon and brought back a recreation for the movie’s 70th anniversary in 2017. Harold is a useful thing to watch for on a rewatch, even if you already know every line of the Santa trial.

Where did the filmmakers shoot the store scenes?

Macy’s Herald Square is a real location and appears in the production record. The 1942 archive photograph below shows what shopping at Macy’s looked like a few winters earlier. The image shows a real shop full of shoppers, years before a film crew arrived to tell the story of its most famous fictional employee.

Customers crowd a decorated aisle inside Macy’s department store in December 1942

Exterior photograph by Eden, Janine and Jim, CC BY 2.0, cropped and resized. December 1942 department-store photograph from the Farm Security Administration and Office of War Information collection at the Library of Congress, no known restrictions.

Where Was A Christmas Story Filmed? The Real House, Higbee’s and Toronto traces a similar holiday shopping scene back to a different real department store. The Real Polar Express Train, Explained follows another kind of borrowing, in which a real locomotive supplied the model and sounds for a film.

Which Miracle on 34th Street has the 1946 footage?

Look for the 1947 film with Edmund Gwenn and Natalie Wood. That’s the version the AFI and Macy’s identify with the 1946 parade. If a listing omits the year, the cast will save you the trouble of working it out from a thumbnail. The same change of reference point can matter in other retellings, as Cinderella’s Glass Slipper: Disney, Perrault, and Grimm shows.

The parade is about to have a milestone of its own. Macy’s has announced its 100th edition for Thanksgiving 2026. The version on the movie screen remains a record of part of the 1946 event, woven into a story about a man who might actually be Santa.

Sources and further reading

Frequently asked questions

What did the production film at the real parade?

The AFI Catalog records filming both at Macy’s and during its Thanksgiving parade. TCM’s production history adds that Edmund Gwenn rode on the actual Santa float. So the actor really did wave to a New York crowd as Santa, even though the film’s story about how he got there belongs to the script.

Where did the filmmakers shoot the store scenes?

Macy’s Herald Square is a real location and appears in the production record. The 1942 archive photograph below shows what shopping at Macy’s looked like a few winters earlier. The image shows a real shop full of shoppers, years before a film crew arrived to tell the story of its most famous fictional employee.

Which Miracle on 34th Street has the 1946 footage?

Look for the 1947 film with Edmund Gwenn and Natalie Wood. That’s the version the AFI and Macy’s identify with the 1946 parade. If a listing omits the year, the cast will save you the trouble of working it out from a thumbnail. The same change of reference point can matter in other retellings, as Cinderella’s Glass Slipper: Disney, Perrault, and Grimm shows.

Sources

Report a correction

Make Red Reactions a preferred source

Choose Red Reactions as a preferred source in Google Search.

Continue reading

Is Bedford Falls From It’s a Wonderful Life a Real Town?