feature · movies

A Christmas Carol’s Ghosts in Order: Who Visits Scrooge in Dickens’s Story?

Marley arrives first, then the three Christmas spirits. See what each shows Scrooge in Dickens’s novella and how it sets up Ti West’s Ebenezer.

By Aram Anwar3 min read
Jacob Marley’s chained ghost visits Ebenezer Scrooge beside the fire in John Leech’s 1843 illustration
John Leech’s 1843 illustration of Marley’s visit to Scrooge. It depicts the source novella.John Leech / Wikimedia Commons / Public domain

Jacob Marley visits first. The Ghosts of Christmas Past, Christmas Present and Christmas Yet to Come follow, in that order. Dickens gives Ebenezer Scrooge four supernatural visitors in A Christmas Carol, including three Christmas spirits. Marley is the one who tells him to expect the other three.

Ti West’s Ebenezer, which opened in U.S. theaters on November 13, uses Dickens’s 1843 ghost story as its starting point. Paramount’s film guide identifies Ian McKellen as Marley, Andrea Riseborough as Christmas Past and Tramell Tillman as Christmas Present. The guide below follows the book and discusses its ending.

What each visitor shows Scrooge

VisitorWhere in the bookWhat Scrooge sees
Jacob MarleyStave OneHis former business partner returns in chains and warns that Scrooge is making the same choices that condemned him.
Christmas PastStave TwoScenes from his own life, including his lonely childhood, Fezziwig’s party and the relationship he lost as money became his priority.
Christmas PresentStave ThreeChristmas as other people are living it now, from the Cratchits’ dinner to Fred’s gathering. The spirit also shows him the children called Ignorance and Want.
Christmas Yet to ComeStave FourA possible future in which Tiny Tim has died and people treat Scrooge’s own death with indifference or relief.

Lead illustration: John Leech, Marley’s Ghost, from the 1843 edition, via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain. Resized and converted to WebP.

Why Marley has a different job

Marley gives Scrooge a deadline. He explains why the visits matter by showing where a life spent putting business first can lead. Past then takes Scrooge back to scenes that make his isolation easier to understand. Fezziwig once managed a business without withholding warmth from the people who worked for him. Scrooge has a real example from his own life of something he could do differently.

Christmas Present brings that choice into the room with the Cratchits. Scrooge pays Bob’s wages, yet has hardly thought about the family those wages support. The spirit’s final reveal of Ignorance and Want moves the question beyond one household. The British Library’s account connects that scene to Dickens’s concerns about childhood poverty.

John Leech’s illustration of the children called Ignorance and Want, with factory chimneys in the distance

Ignorance and Want, illustrated by John Leech for the 1843 edition. British Library, shelfmark Dex.293.(1.). Public domain. Resized and converted to WebP.

Is the future fixed?

In the novella, the last spirit barely communicates beyond gestures. Scrooge has to recognize what he’s seeing, including the name on the gravestone, for himself. He asks whether those events must happen or can still be changed. The final chapter, Stave Five, answers through his actions on Christmas morning.

That progression helps explain why the supernatural encounters have room for both horror and a change of heart. For the adaptation’s trailers and announced screen roles, see our Ebenezer film guide.

Sources & further reading

Sources

#A Christmas Carol#Ebenezer#Charles Dickens#John Leech#Ti WestA Christmas Carol
Report a correction

Make Red Reactions a preferred source

Choose Red Reactions as a preferred source in Google Search.

Related coverage

About the author

Aram Anwar

Founder & Editor

Aram Anwar founded Red Reactions and writes across comics, gaming, movies and television. His work includes franchise guides and large Lore / Explained features, with an emphasis on separating confirmed details from reports, theory and speculation.

Coverage: Comics · DC & Marvel · Gaming · Movies & TV · Lore / Explained · Guides

More from Aram Anwar

Continue reading

Ebenezer Trailer 2: Cast, Ghost Story and November 13 Release