lore · tv

Who Is Pallando in The Rings of Power? Tolkien’s Blue Wizards Explained

Season 3 names the Dark Wizard as Pallando. Here is what happened to his companion in Rhûn and how Tolkien’s accounts of the Blue Wizards differ.

By Aram Anwar4 min read

The printed title page of The Silmarillion, naming J.R.R. Tolkien and editor Christopher Tolkien.
The Silmarillion mentions Wizards who went east, then leaves their story untold. Their names appear in the later-published Unfinished Tales.Stojanoski Slave / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Spoilers through Season 3, Episode 3. The Dark Wizard in The Rings of Power is Pallando, played by Ciarán Hinds. In “The Secret Fire,” Gandalf learns that Pallando was one of two Wizards sent east and that he murdered his companion. Tolkien wrote about a Blue Wizard named Pallando, and he entertained the possibility that the two Wizards failed. The murder and Gandalf’s mission to bring Pallando back are the show’s additions. Prime Video’s scene · Patrick McKay’s interview

What the Secret Fire tells Gandalf

Pallando calls Gandalf an old friend when they meet in the Season 2 finale. The Season 3 reveal gives that greeting a history. In the episode, the Secret Fire tells Gandalf that Pallando belonged to their order, betrayed the Wizard sent with him and devastated Rhûn. The companion goes unnamed in the scene. Alatar is the name of Pallando’s partner in Tolkien’s notes. Prime Video’s Season 3 episode listing · J.D. Payne and Daniel Weyman’s Radio Times interview

The Secret Fire asks Gandalf to save Pallando so they can keep Rhûn’s forces from joining Sauron. That turns the earlier offer of friendship into a test for Gandalf. He has to decide whether a fellow Wizard who has already used his power to dominate others can choose a different course. Co-creator Patrick McKay said the writers built the story around the murder and the possibility that Pallando might feel guilt or want redemption. McKay’s CinemaBlend interview

Who were Tolkien’s Blue Wizards?

The Blue Wizards belong to the Istari, the order of emissaries sent to help Middle-earth resist Sauron. Appendix B of The Lord of the Rings places the Wizards’ appearance around the year 1000 of the Third Age. The Silmarillion, in “Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age,” says other Wizards went east and leaves their story there. The Silmarillion, publisher edition

The essay “The Istari” in Unfinished Tales calls the pair Ithryn Luin, meaning Blue Wizards. They travel east with Saruman and never return to the West, where the account is set. The text leaves open whether they continued their work, died, or fell into Sauron’s service. Christopher Tolkien prints related notes in the same chapter that name the pair Alatar and Pallando. In those notes, Alatar takes Pallando along as a friend. Unfinished Tales, Part Four, “The Istari”

Tolkien sounded more pessimistic in his 1958 letter to Rhona Beare. He suspected that the two had failed in ways different from Saruman’s and might have started secret cults and traditions of magic. He expressed both ideas as guesses. The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, letter 211

Tolkien later imagined that the two Wizards made a difference

In “The Five Wizards,” a late note printed in The Peoples of Middle-earth, Tolkien calls the two Morinehtar and Rómestámo, glossed as Darkness-slayer and East-helper. He sends them to Middle-earth in the Second Age, much earlier than the Wizards’ appearance in Appendix B. Their job is to help peoples who resist Sauron and disrupt his forces in the East. The note says they fail to find his hiding place after his first fall, yet suggests their work kept the East from overwhelming the West. The Peoples of Middle-earth, chapter XIII, pp. 384–85 in the 1996 Houghton Mifflin edition

Prime Video uses the earlier name Pallando in a Second Age setting that has a precedent in Tolkien’s later work. Its account of the murder takes the story in a different direction. In the late notes, the pair’s success is measured partly by how many forces never reach the war. The show makes that same threat a problem for one Wizard to solve by reaching the other. For the larger timeline, see our comparison of The Rings of Power and Tolkien’s Second Age.

Where to read about Pallando

Start with “The Istari” in Part Four of Unfinished Tales for the name Pallando and the story of the two Wizards’ departure. Then read “The Five Wizards” in chapter XIII of The Peoples of Middle-earth for Tolkien’s later account of their assignment and its effect on the war. The two books preserve distinct versions, so either one on its own gives an incomplete picture of Tolkien’s thinking.

Title-page photograph by Stojanoski Slave via Wikimedia Commons. The previously cropped, rotated and resized image is reused under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Sources

#The Rings of Power#J.R.R. Tolkien#Pallando#Blue Wizards#Istari#Rhûn#GandalfThe Lord of the Rings
Report a correction

Make Red Reactions a preferred source

Choose Red Reactions as a preferred source in Google Search.

Related coverage

PreviousThe Rings of Power vs Tolkien: What the Show Gets Wrong About the Second Age

About the author

Aram Anwar

Founder & Editor

Aram Anwar founded Red Reactions and writes across comics, gaming, movies and television. His work includes franchise guides and large Lore / Explained features, with an emphasis on separating confirmed details from reports, theory and speculation.

Coverage: Comics · DC & Marvel · Gaming · Movies & TV · Lore / Explained · Guides

More from Aram Anwar

Continue reading

The One Ring Explained: What It Does, Why Sauron Forged It and Why It Corrupts