feature · tv

The Rings of Power vs Tolkien: What the Show Gets Wrong About the Second Age

How The Rings of Power changes Tolkien’s Second Age, from the order of the Rings and Númenor’s timeline to Galadriel, mithril, Adar and Gandalf.

By Aram Anwar7 min read
The printed title page of The Silmarillion, naming J.R.R. Tolkien and editor Christopher Tolkien.
An English edition of Tolkien’s Silmarillion. Its final two sections cover Númenor and the history of the Rings of Power.Stojanoski Slave / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Tolkien puts the One Ring before the fall of Eregion. The Rings of Power puts it after. That reversal changes what starts the war, and it matters more than whether Galadriel carries a sword. The show also puts Elendil and Isildur in the same generation as the forging, bringing together events Tolkien separated by about 1,700 years.

Spoilers: This guide covers Seasons 1 and 2, plus the publicly announced Season 3 setup. The main book references are The Lord of the Rings, Appendix B, and the last two sections of The Silmarillion.

TopicIn TolkienIn the series
The order of the RingsCelebrimbor completes the Three near the end. Sauron forges the One before Eregion falls.The Three come first. The One is still unmade in the Season 3 setup, five years after Eregion falls.
NúmenorThe One is forged around Second Age 1600. Númenor falls in 3319.Elendil and Isildur are already active when the Three are made.
Sauron and GaladrielAnnatar wins over the smiths of Eregion. Galadriel’s Second Age biography exists in several versions.Halbrand wins Galadriel’s trust before returning as Annatar. Celeborn is a missing husband who returns in Season 3.
MithrilA rare metal linked to Moria and used in Galadriel’s ring.A legend connects it to a Silmaril, and mithril becomes an urgent answer to the Elves’ fading.
Gandalf and the HarfootsThe Wizards appear in the Third Age in Appendix B. The early history of Hobbits is largely unrecorded.The Stranger meets the Harfoots in the Second Age and is identified as Gandalf.

1. Reordering the Rings changes why the war begins

In Appendix B, the smiths of Eregion start their great work around 1500 of the Second Age. Celebrimbor completes the Three around 1590. Sauron forges the One in Mount Doom around 1600, the Elves recognize the trap, and Eregion falls in 1697. In The Silmarillion, “Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age,” Celebrimbor makes the Three himself. Sauron never touches them, though their power is still bound up with the One. The Tolkien Estate’s chronology

The show starts with the Three at the end of Season 1. Halbrand suggests the technique that helps the smiths use their small amount of mithril. His departure comes before the Three are made. He returns as Annatar and works with Celebrimbor on the Seven and Nine in Season 2. In the Season 3 setup, Sauron is still trying to make the One five years after the fall of Eregion. About Amazon’s first-season recap · Prime Video’s Season 3 premise

The effect is bigger than a date change. Tolkien makes the One a trap the Elves discover, helping set the war in motion. The show makes it a weapon Sauron is trying to finish in a war already underway. It also gives the Seven and Nine their Dwarf and human destinations during the design process. In The Silmarillion, they begin as Elven works and acquire those associations when Sauron distributes the Rings. Appendix A preserves a Dwarvish tradition that the Elven-smiths gave Durin III his ring themselves. For the mechanics, see what the One Ring actually does.

2. Númenor loses centuries of history

Appendix B dates Sauron’s arrival as a captive in Númenor to 3262 and the island’s Downfall to 3319. Elendil and Isildur belong to the final phase of the island’s history. The show already has an adult Isildur and his father Elendil on screen in the same season that Celebrimbor makes the Three. About Amazon’s first-season recap

Co-creator J.D. Payne explained that centuries-long jumps would keep replacing the human cast. The cost is visible in Númenor’s story. In Tolkien, the island’s fear of death turns into policy and rebellion across generations. The series has to carry much of that history through the decisions of one family and one court. J.D. Payne’s Vanity Fair interview · Tolkien’s letter to Milton Waldman

3. Halbrand gives Sauron a different way in

The published Silmarillion gives Sauron the fair guise of Annatar, the Lord of Gifts. The smiths of Eregion accept his instruction. Gil-galad and Elrond distrust him and keep him out of Lindon. The first season invents Halbrand, a man Galadriel takes for a lost Southlands heir, and uses that relationship to put Sauron in reach of Celebrimbor. About Amazon’s Sauron explainer

The second season’s Annatar is one of the adaptation’s closest matches. He gets to Celebrimbor through the smith’s pride and desire to make something lasting. That is the trap Tolkien set for Eregion. The surprise identity in Season 1 is the show’s own route to it. For the identities in order, see our Sauron guide.

4. Galadriel’s pursuit and Celeborn’s disappearance

The show centers Galadriel’s early story on her hunt for Sauron after her brother Finrod’s death. It also has her tell Theo in Season 1 that she never saw her husband Celeborn again after he went to war. Prime Video brings Celeborn into Season 3 as her long-lost husband. Season 1, “The Eye” · Prime Video’s Season 3 cast guide

Tolkien wrote a formidable Galadriel whose pride and ambition to govern a realm help explain why she leaves the West. One account in Unfinished Tales, “Concerning Galadriel and Celeborn,” has her distrust Annatar while the smiths listen to him. Tolkien revised the couple’s movements and history several times. The show’s missing-husband story and Halbrand partnership are specific inventions. The argument that a physically capable Galadriel contradicts Tolkien is much weaker. Christopher Tolkien’s introduction to Unfinished Tales

5. The show gives mithril a new purpose

In Season 1, the Elves consider a legend in which a Silmaril’s light passes into the mountain and produces mithril. The episode treats the tale as apocryphal. A piece of the ore later restores a blighted leaf, and the smiths use mithril in the Three as they look for a way to stop the Elves’ fading. Season 1, “Partings” and “The Eye”

In The Fellowship of the Ring, “A Journey in the Dark” describes mithril as a light, hard and precious metal. In The Return of the King, “The Grey Havens” identifies it as the metal in Galadriel’s ring, Nenya. The books give it no Silmaril origin. Tolkien did connect Elven ring-making to slowing change and decay. The series turns that desire for preservation into an immediate crisis with a mineral cure. Tolkien’s letter to Milton Waldman

6. Gandalf arrives early, and the Harfoots fill a gap

Season 2 identifies the Stranger as Gandalf. Appendix B puts the appearance of the Istari, or Wizards, around 1000 of the Third Age; Appendix B also describes Gandalf arriving from the West and Círdan giving him Narya. Later writings consider a Second Age arrival for the two Blue Wizards. Those notes leave Gandalf’s familiar Third Age mission in place. The show moves his recognizably Gandalf story into the Second Age. Season 2 finale interview

The Harfoots are a different case. Appendix B first records them entering Eriador around Third Age 1050, and the prologue to The Lord of the Rings treats Hobbit origins as poorly documented. Earlier Harfoot communities are an invention built into that gap. Gandalf’s placement is the clearer departure.

For the later reveal and Tolkien’s other drafts, see our spoiler-marked guide to the Dark Wizard and the Blue Wizards.

7. Adar is invented, but his Orc ancestry has a source

Adar and his role in the Southlands are original to the show. The published Silmarillion, in “Of the Coming of the Elves and the Captivity of Melkor,” attributes to the Wise of Eressëa the belief that some of the first Orcs were made from captured, corrupted Elves. Tolkien later explored other origins in writings collected in Morgoth’s Ring. The show turns one of those possible origins into a named character with motives and relationships of his own. The Silmarillion, publisher edition

Where to read Tolkien’s Second Age

  1. Start with Appendix B, “The Second Age,” in The Lord of the Rings for the order of the Rings, Eregion, Númenor and the Last Alliance.
  2. Read “Akallabêth” and “Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age” near the end of The Silmarillion for the fall of Númenor and the purpose of the Rings.
  3. Read “Concerning Galadriel and Celeborn” in Unfinished Tales for the places where Tolkien kept revising their story.

The One Ring’s place in the war is the clearest factual departure. Númenor’s missing centuries change the tragedy most. Both are worth separating from additions such as Adar, which show what an adaptation can build from a genuine uncertainty in the source. For a verdict on how the first two seasons work as television, see our Rings of Power review.

Title-page photo by Stojanoski Slave via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped, rotated and resized. The resulting image is available under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Sources

Report a correction

Make Red Reactions a preferred source

Choose Red Reactions as a preferred source in Google Search.

Related coverage

PreviousWho Are the Nazgûl in The Rings of Power Season 3? Khamûl and the Nine ExplainedNextWho Is Pallando in The Rings of Power? Tolkien’s Blue Wizards Explained

About the author

Aram Anwar

Founder & Editor

Aram Anwar founded Red Reactions and writes across comics, gaming, movies and television. His work includes franchise guides and large Lore / Explained features, with an emphasis on separating confirmed details from reports, theory and speculation.

Coverage: Comics · DC & Marvel · Gaming · Movies & TV · Lore / Explained · Guides

More from Aram Anwar

Continue reading

The Rings of Power Review: Beautiful Middle-earth, but Not Enough Tolkien